This blog post was originally published in November 2017 and was updated in September 2025 with updated FAQs and our comprehensive top best practices for preventing short payments.
What is a short-paid invoice?
Any credit, finance, and collections manager will tell you that short pays wreak havoc on every organization’s ability to manage time, resources, and cash flow. There is no way to avoid short payments, and it can be difficult to manage them. Let’s take a few steps back and first understand what short pays are, why they happen, and how to reduce them, including using accounts receivable (AR) software. A short pay is a partial payment of an invoice, which can occur for any reason. Short pays can happen when a buyer feels the contracted work or services have not been fulfilled, or they can be used as a stalling tactic to avoid paying the entire amount due.
So, what else do you need to know about short pays in order to come up with a strategy to deal with them efficiently?
Why do organizations short pay invoices?
There are so many reasons to short pay an invoice, but most reasons fall into one of two categories – valid and invalid. Some of the legitimate, expected reasons include:
- A shipment of goods arrived damaged
- Not all goods or services were provided on time as agreed
- Trade promotions and other marketing discounts which are not listed in the invoice
- Sales discount extended to a customer that is not reflected in the pricing and invoicing system
- Earned discounts for early payment
- Payment plan negotiated with collections team
There are also buyers who will unexpectedly short pay invoices for invalid reasons, or reasons which were not agreed up by the supplier. Some of these may include:
- Buyer is short on cash and can’t pay full invoice
- Human error
- Unearned discount – taking advantage of an early pay discount after the deadline
- Buyer only pays some invoices, not all, and doesn’t provide complete remittance information, complicating the cash application process
- Payment tactic to manage cash flow
- Business strategy with the hopes that the supplier will write off the short pay
The impact of short-paid invoices on businesses
Short payments can disrupt cash flow, strain supplier relationships, and increase administrative burdens. They can lead to:
- Operational disruptions: Difficulty in budgeting and forecasting due to inconsistent cash flow.
- Increased administrative costs: More time and resources needed for reconciliation and dispute management.
- Potential legal and contractual issues: If short payments persist, it may lead to legal disputes or renegotiations of terms.
Read now → Manage short-pays with credit management strategies [ Blog ]
What is the difference between deduction management and dispute management?
The real question to ask is, are these expected short pays or unexpected short pays? While both of these strategies deal with short pays, they handle the two very different aspects of this time-consuming problem. Deduction management refers to the technology and strategies used for dealing with valid, or expected short pays, and will usually be handled by your accounts receivable (AR) team. Dispute management is the methodology you use for dealing with unexpected, invalid short pays, and will often be handled by a separate collections team, if your organization has one.
Deduction management is how your team keeps track of expected short pays, such as marketing deductions, sales rebates, early pay discounts, and other markdowns which would lower the amount owed by customers. Any short pays due to a legitimate, agreed upon deduction, falls within the terms of the buyer-supplier contract and doesn’t require much effort beyond a simple verification process.
Dispute management places a burden on your AR team to solve the unknown problem of unexpected short pays. At first glance, it appears that the buyer has decided not to pay the entire invoice for an unknown reason. Your collections team is now tasked with calling the buyer, finding out the reason for the short pay, and then tracking down information within your organization to figure out whether or not the reason is valid. For example, if the buyer claims a shipment arrived damaged, you’re going to have to track down documentation and evidence to support or refute that claim. Tracking data will allow your organization to identify trends (such as a shipping department quality control issue which can be resolved).
How do you fix short pays?
The truth is, no business can ever get rid of short pays completely. But the use of tactical strategies and the right technology can help any business create long-term solutions which reduce the number of short pays.
To mitigate the occurrence of short payments and ensure timely settlements, you need to come up with a strategy and set up processes so the occurrence of short pays happen less frequently. The key lies in prevention, where proactive measures are taken to address this issue effectively.
Efficient resolution of short pays requires a structured approach:
- Identify the reason: Determine if the short pay is due to a valid deduction or an error/dispute.
- Communicate with the buyer: Reach out promptly to clarify the issue and gather necessary information.
- Document and verify: Maintain thorough documentation to support your position and resolve disputes.
- Negotiate if necessary: Engage in negotiations to address any discrepancies and reach a mutually agreeable solution.
Our top 8 best practices for preventing and managing short payments:
To avoid situations of short payments, consider this:
1. Establish Crystal-Clear Terms from Day One
Prevention starts before the first invoice is even sent. During the customer onboarding process, it’s crucial to clearly communicate and document all payment terms. Create an official policy that outlines:
- Acceptable payment methods
- Due dates
- Potential late fees or penalties
- Your specific process for handling and disputing invoice discrepancies
When both parties understand the expectations from the outset, there’s far less room for misunderstanding later on.
2. Leverage AR Automation for Speed and Accuracy
Manual processes are prone to human error—a leading cause of legitimate short payments. A unified, AI-powered accounts receivable (AR) platform is your best defense.
- Invoice Promptly & Accurately: Automation ensures invoices are generated and sent the moment an order is fulfilled, with all details perfectly matching the agreed-upon terms.
- Streamline Payments: An online payment portal not only makes it easy for customers to pay how and when they prefer, but when integrated with your AR system, it eliminates errors in cash application by automatically linking payment and remittance data.
- Centralize Dispute Management: Modern AR platforms have built-in dispute management tools. This allows customers to log a reason for a short payment (e.g., “damaged goods”) directly on the invoice, giving your collections team all the information they need to resolve it quickly.
Billtrust’s Cash Application solution automatically identifies partial payments and flags them for review, helping you maintain accurate records without manual intervention. This automation controls costs by reducing the time your team spends on reconciliation while accelerating your cash application process.
3. Maintain Proactive and Open Communication
Don’t wait for a problem to arise before you talk to your customers.
- Send Intelligent, Timely Reminders: Go beyond generic reminders. Modern collections solutions use AI-driven, behavior-based workflows to automate and personalize outreach. These Agentic Procedures can recommend the optimal timing and channel for reminders based on a customer’s payment history, ensuring the message is a helpful nudge, not an annoyance.
- Follow Up Immediately: The moment a short payment is identified, reach out to your customer to understand the discrepancy. An immediate, non-confrontational inquiry shows you’re on top of your accounts and helps resolve the issue while it’s still fresh in everyone’s mind.
4. Implement a Robust Dispute Resolution Process
When a customer disputes a charge, how you handle it matters. Have a well-defined internal process for investigating and resolving issues swiftly. This should include identifying who is responsible for investigating different types of claims (e.g., shipping department for delivery issues, sales for pricing discrepancies) and setting a timeline for resolution. A fast, professional resolution process builds trust and encourages customers to communicate issues directly rather than simply short-paying an invoice.
Cases, as part of Billtrust’s enhanced Collections platform, makes managing disputes a lot easier. Disputes raised through the billing and payments portal directly flow into the Collections platform, where they are automatically tracked, paused from dunning workflows, and managed in a centralized portal.
5. Conduct Root Cause Analysis
Instead of just fixing individual short payments, dig deeper. Use a robust collections analytics dashboard to regularly track and analyze why they happen. Are you seeing a pattern?
- Is it always the same customer?
- Is it always related to freight charges?
- Do discrepancies often happen with a specific product?
By leveraging clear, actionable insights and industry-standard KPIs like the Collections Effectiveness Index (CEI), you can identify the root cause. Furthermore, AI assistants like Billtrust Autopilot can proactively flag unusual trends and anomalies, allowing you to fix the underlying issue before it impacts cash flow.
6. Foster Cross-Departmental Collaboration
Accounts receivable is often the last stop in a long chain of events. A short payment could stem from an error made in sales, warehousing, or shipping. Create clear communication channels between your AR team and other departments. When the sales team understands how pricing errors affect collections, or the shipping department sees the financial impact of damaged goods, everyone can work together to ensure the customer is billed correctly the first time.
7. Monitor Accounts and Use Credit Controls Wisely
Vigilance is key, but manual monitoring isn’t scalable. Modern AR platforms seamlessly integrate credit risk information with collections operations. With automated triggers and scheduled credit reviews, the system can proactively flag an account for review when its payment behavior changes. For customers who repeatedly short-pay, you can take action—like adjusting credit limits—from within a single, intelligent workflow. This transforms credit management from a reactive chore into a proactive strategy to minimize bad debt.
8. Incentivize Full, On-Time Payments
A carrot can be just as effective as a stick. Consider offering a small discount for early payment (e.g., a “2/10, n/30” term, which offers a 2% discount if paid in 10 days). This incentivizes customers to pay the full amount promptly, reducing the window for potential disputes and improving your cash flow simultaneously.
Learn more about short pays by reading the Billtrust blog post, “Short pays: Why they happen and what you can do about them.”
How to implement a robust deduction management system
Implementing a robust deduction management system involves:
- Integration with accounting software: Ensure your deduction management system integrates seamlessly with your existing accounting software for accurate tracking.
- Regular audits: Conduct regular audits to identify any discrepancies and ensure deductions are applied correctly.
- Training for staff: Provide training for your team on how to handle deductions and resolve issues effectively.
Read now → Reduce disputes by lowering your credit card processing fees [ Blog ]
Bringing It All Together
Preventing and managing short payments requires a multi-faceted strategy. While each of the best practices discussed can lead to incremental improvements, their true power is unlocked when they operate in concert. Adopting a single, unified, and intelligent platform connects every step—from invoicing and payments to dispute management and credit reviews. This provides the complete visibility and control needed to take your entire AR process to the next level, reduce manual effort, and protect your cash flow with strategic precision.
See how Billtrust’s AI-powered platform for Collections and Cash Application can help you prevent discrepancies, automate dispute management, and accelerate cash flow.
Schedule a personalized demo.
Frequently Asked Questions
Check out the FAQs for general questions. Find helpful answers quickly to get the information you need.
What is the meaning of short billing?
Short billing occurs when the invoiced or billed amount is less than what was agreed upon or expected. It indicates an undercharge for goods or services provided.
What does short paid mean?
“Short paid” refers to a situation in which the amount of money paid for a bill, invoice, or obligation is less than what is actually owed. This can occur due to an oversight, error in calculation, or deliberate underpayment. In such cases, the payer may be required to settle the remaining balance to fulfill the payment obligation fully.
What is the difference between a short pay and a deduction?
A short pay occurs when you receive less than the full invoice amount. Deductions are a specific type of short pay that you’ve agreed to in advance with your customer — such as trade discounts, rebates, or early payment incentives. When you encounter unexpected short pays without clear reasoning, they typically require investigation through your dispute management process.
Is a short-paid invoice a dispute?
Not necessarily. If the short payment corresponds to a valid, pre-agreed deduction, it’s part of your normal business process. However, when the reason for the short payment is unclear or unexpected, it becomes a dispute that your AR team needs to resolve. Billtrust’s Collections solution helps you quickly identify and categorize these situations to accelerate resolution.
Can you write off a short pay?
You may choose to write off small remaining balances when the cost of collection exceeds the potential recovery amount. This decision should align with your internal policies and consider factors like the outstanding amount, collection costs, and the customer’s payment history. The key is having clear criteria that help you make consistent decisions that control costs while maintaining customer relationships.
